Release Date: 2009
Label: Jagjaguwar
It’s clear that (most of the time) musicians should never reunite after 10+ years of an irresolute hiatus. With this, Dinosaur Jr. doesn’t apply. But there are a few problems: does it really seem not loud enough? I’ve already checked my volume levels and what is audible from these speakers can only be surmised as tame. Almost too tame. The critic side of me notes this as a fault, but the human side of me is heartbroken. Although Farm ranks second to 87’s You’re Living All Over Me, (and maybe between the quadrants of Bug or Green Mind ), there’s something that still isn’t there. The quiet-loud dynamic seems muffled, J Mascis’s guitar is louder than his voice (as usual), and through all of this I couldn’t even come up with another pot pie analogy. I’m stumped.
So let’s rewind to the Meat Puppets. Remember that album Rise to Your Knees? Remember how painful it was to listen to the opening track, realizing that your old, precious Curt Kirkwood seemed washed out and confused? I was as baffled as him. And it would be no exaggeration to say the memories of that record still haunt me, almost as much as Laura Dern’s face in Inland Empire. Although, through time I learned to forgive the Puppets, with this exception made solely on their proceeding, and most recent release, Sewn Together. The leak dropped, and I was in bliss. Each track complimented the next, beautifully reflecting ye olde Puppets days.
Farm is like Sewn Together. It’s the album that proves they’re still awesome, genuinely matured and ultimately proving they can in fact get back into the groove. Of course it’s not an all around accurate groove (circa ’87-’94), but it’s definitely there, and that’s enough. It’s like turning on a modern rock record, without reeking of the modern rock typicals. There aren’t any wussy ballads, the guitar is tastefully unclean and despite its protruding aggression, there are still emotional moments to be had –the chewy nougat, if you will. For me, that moment is in the last two minutes or so of “Ocean in the Way:” a complete flashback moment, so Green Mind-esque it makes you sick. You almost feel bad for Mascis, crooning gently as his instrument responds similarly, and (predictably) jumping into a complete resurgence of a classic Dino Jr. wallop.
The real reasoning for my less-than-perfect critique refers only to a few tracks. “I Don’t Wanna Go There” actually reminds me of a Pearl Jam song. And yes, there are several instances in this track where Mascis starts pulling an Eddie Vedder, but all is forgiven after another melodic and driving solo from J’s outrageously loud guitar, (and if you listen closely, you might actually hear some drums.) But the Vedder is only one of the many voices of Mascis. The classic Mascis is usually what I prefer, but in some occurrences you can detect the sort of secret grungy region, exemplified from a cracking voice, maybe a few grunts. Don’t try to hide behind that feedback crap, J, it’s obvious to see where those 90s bands learned to sing.
Complaints aside, I will always devote my heart to J Mascis’s voice. My shtick has usually been the creepy fangirl, anyway. And I don’t mind. It should be okay that I want to cuddle with his vocal chords, maybe take them out to a picture show, hope they’ll call me the next day and pray it’s not too Vedder-esque.
So after finally buying the album on vinyl and throwing on the double LP for careful consideration, I have categorically decided Farm is among one of the best Dinosaur Jr. records I’ve ever heard. They do what few bands can do after a 10 year hiatus. Dinosaur Jr. is beloved, and who certainly didn’t tarnish their legacy; this isn’t your stinkin’ Smashing Pumpkins revival.
Cool stuff to check out:
“Over It”
Myspace
The secret link